If a house has been sitting on the market for months, does that mean something's wrong with it—or could it be a great opportunity?
Answered by Steve Rath | Broker-Owner at Rath Real Estate. California DRE #01020976. Serving Sacramento, Placer & El Dorado Counties. | LinkedIn Zillow Realtor.com steverath.com
Short Answer
Both! When I'm representing a buyer, these are exactly the properties I investigate. A home that's been sitting unsold might be overpriced, poorly marketed, badly presented, or hiding a problem that looks much worse than it is. Sometimes there's a very good reason nobody has bought it. Other times, there's an opportunity everyone else has overlooked.
In-Depth Answer
When I'm working for a buyer, I'm an aggressive Hunter Gatherer.
And homes that have been sitting on the market for months? Those are among the first places I go hunting.
Not because every stale listing is a bargain. Far from it. But because I want to know WHY hasn't this house sold?
And the answer can be very interesting.
Sometimes the problem isn't the house.
It's the marketing, pricing strategy, or presentation.
A perfectly good property can sit because the listing agent hasn't presented it properly, the photography is terrible, or the pricing strategy was wrong from the beginning.
Sometimes it's a stubborn seller whose brother, neighbor, or somebody else told them what the house should sell for. Or they saw a house down the street sell for a certain amount last year and refuse to recognize the differences between the properties—or the market.
And sometimes the numbers simply don't work for the seller. They paid this, owe that, and the market is somewhere else entirely.
None of those things automatically makes it a bad house.
Here's where sellers can get themselves into serious trouble.
I've never liked the strategy of pricing a property too high without a compelling justification and saying:
"They can always offer less."
Or:
"We'll test the market and reduce the price if it doesn't sell."
In my opinion, those can be terrible pricing strategies.
First, an unjustifiably high price can chase away the active buyers who might otherwise have been interested.
Second, when the price finally drops, buyers begin asking the very question we're discussing:
What's wrong with it?
Then they start watching for the next reduction.
And the next.
In a declining market, this can become what Realtors call chasing the market down. Instead of getting ahead of the market, the seller is always trying to catch up with it.
That's why identifying the right pricing tipping point—and understanding why it's right—is so important.
But what if there really IS something wrong with the house?
Now we're getting somewhere.
Some of the best opportunities involve problems that buyers, sellers, and even agents dramatically overestimate.
Take a large pest inspection report.
To an inexperienced buyer, it can look terrifying. Termites! Dry rot! Damaged wood! A long list of repairs and a frightening estimate.
But a long report doesn't necessarily mean a disastrous house.
Pest companies have responsibilities and potential liability associated with their inspections and clearance work. Their reports may identify numerous conditions requiring attention, and their repair estimates can be substantially different from what qualified independent contractors might charge.
I've seen situations where a seemingly enormous problem turned out to be relatively straightforward and inexpensive to correct.
I can't tell you how many times I've watched buyers walk into a house, see a kitchen that needs updating, and immediately start doing imaginary math.
"Ohhh, that's $50,000 for the kitchen. Another $30,000 for the bathrooms. Flooring? $30,000. Painting, $25,000. Opening that wall? At least $25,000."
And just like that, they've mentally spent $160,000 without getting a single estimate.
Sometimes they say it out loud. Sometimes they don't, which is even worse because I don't get the chance to correct their assumptions.
I've seen buyers estimate costs at three, four, even five times what I know certain improvements can actually be completed for.
And the same thing happens with pest repairs.
Of course, actual costs depend on the property, the scope of work, and who's doing it. But the important thing is to replace imaginary numbers with realistic ones before making a decision.
Because the house they just rejected might have been an exceptional opportunity.
And here's the other side of that coin.
When I'm representing a seller, I work to eliminate those perceived problems before buyers ever walk through the door.
Sometimes that means actually making improvements. Other times, it's about preparation, presentation, and knowing how buyers perceive what they're seeing.
My goal is to keep buyers from mentally deducting $160,000 for improvements that might cost a fraction of that amount.
And sometimes the real trick is removing the appearance of a costly problem—even when the underlying work hasn't been done.
Of course, some problems really are serious. The trick is knowing the difference.
What exactly is wrong? What will it take to fix it properly? What will it actually cost? And does the purchase price more than compensate for the work and risk?
That's the investigation.
If the seller or listing agent sees a disaster where I see a manageable repair, there may be a substantial opportunity for my buyer.
And if the problem really is a disaster?
We move on.
So what's my answer?
A home sitting on the market for months could be a bad buy.
It could also be one of the best opportunities in the neighborhood.
The important question isn't how long it's been sitting. It's WHY—and what that means for the buyer.
That's what I go hunting for.
Steve's Advice
A stale listing is a question, not a verdict. Find out why it hasn't sold. If the answer is pricing, marketing, or a problem that only looks expensive, it may be the best opportunity in the neighborhood.
Related Questions
Keep Reading
Why Do Some Homes Sell Quickly While Others Sit?
The ONLY reason a home doesn't sell is......wait for it......PRICE. It's priced too high.
Read the full answer Buying SmartHow Can I Tell if the Price Is Fair?
Never—and I do mean never—rely on an online valuation website or its algorithm to decide what a property is actually worth.
Read the full answerStill Have a Question?
Talk to You Soon
Your question isn't covered yet? Ask me directly and I will give you a straight answer. No pressure, no games, just a real conversation about your real estate goals.
Prefer to talk? Call or text 916-834-9792.